Finding a decent pair of boxer shorts shouldn’t be this complicated. And yet here I am, having worn my way through multiple brands so I can give you something more useful than “they’re boxers, they’re fine.”
Every pair on this list has been bought with my own money. No free pairs, no brand deals. No marketing BS, no sponsored content. That’s the No BS Reviews promise.
I’m adding to this page as I work through the full list, so check back for updated scores and new entries.
Overall Brand Scores
How I score: comfort, breathability, riding up (or not), leg length clarity, value for money and how they hold up after washing. First impressions count, but durability is the real test.
| Brand | Overall Score |
|---|---|
| PUMA Active Stretch Boxer | 8.5/10 |
| On That Ass | 8.5/10 |
| Under Armour Performance Boxer | 8/10 |
| OddBalls Cotton Boxers | 7/10 |
| Bawbag | Review in progress |
From the Geeky Gorevan Lab
No BS Comparison Reviews
Bought with my own money. Tested properly. No sponsored fluff.
PUMA Active Stretch Boxer 8.5/10
The best value on this list. Four pairs for £16.42 (that’s just over £4 a pair) and they’re genuinely good. Cotton stretch material that feels breathable and comfortable from the first wear, no riding up, and a cut that sits well without feeling too short. Plain colours only, so if you’re after bold prints these aren’t for you, but if you want a workhorse everyday boxer at a price that makes sense, it’s hard to look past PUMA here.
| Category | Score | My Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Feels great from the moment you put them on |
| Breathability | 9/10 | Cotton stretch does its job |
| Riding Up | 10/10 | None – zero issues |
| Leg Length | 7/10 | No long leg option, but the cut doesn’t feel too short |
| Design / Range | 5/10 | Plain colours only |
| Value for Money | 10/10 | £4 a pair for this quality is exceptional |
Under Armour Performance Boxer – 8/10
Under Armour have a reputation for performance kit and it carries into their boxer range. Cotton stretch, breathable, comfortable — no riding up and not too short despite having no specific long leg option. The price point is the other standout: around £3 a pair from a three-pack. Plain colours, no frills, just a well-made everyday boxer at a price that genuinely surprises.
| Category | Score | My Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Comfortable and well-fitted |
| Breathability | 8/10 | Breathable, solid all-day wear |
| Riding Up | 10/10 | No issues |
| Leg Length | 7/10 | No long leg option, sits fine though |
| Design / Range | 5/10 | Plain colours only |
| Value for Money | 10/10 | Around £3 a pair — outstanding |
OddBalls Cotton Boxers – 7/10
OddBalls are one of the best-known UK underwear brands, and the designs are genuinely some of the best available – bold, fun prints that stand out from the sea of plain grey and navy you get everywhere else. I picked up a pair in the sale (usually around £12 each).
One thing to know before you order: check whether you’re buying short leg or long leg. I grabbed short leg by mistake, and if you’re used to long leg boxers they feel noticeably brief at first. After a few minutes your body adjusts and they’re comfortable, but it’s worth getting right before the parcel arrives.
Once you’re past that, they’re a solid boxer. Breathable, good fit, no riding up. I want to test their bamboo long leg range to see how the material compares, so watch this space for an updated score.
| Category | Score | My Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 8/10 | Comfy once you adjust to the leg length |
| Breathability | 8/10 | Breathable cotton material |
| Riding Up | 10/10 | None |
| Leg Length | 5/10 | Short leg only in the ones I tried check before you buy (my fault) |
| Design / Range | 10/10 | Some of the best patterns available anywhere |
| Value for Money | 7/10 | £12 a pair is fair; worth watching for sales |
Bawbag
A Scottish brand with a cult following. Known for bold, irreverent designs and a quality that punches above what you’d expect. I haven’t got to these yet, but they’re high on the list especially as a fellow Scot I feel obligated.
Review coming soon.
On That Ass
On That Ass are a subscription boxer brand with a hook that’s hard to ignore… your first pair is free! After that, they send you a new pair every month as part of a subscription, if you decide to continue with them!
I signed up for the free pair, so I would review the boxers, but also let you know how easy (or not so easy) it was to cancel the subscription. (I know that is one of the main questions that my readers have with subscription companies).
So the boxers themselves – They are standard length (not the long leg). They are well constructed, very easy to move in, and the design is top-notch! I got the zombie pair that you can see in the image above and i thought they were brilliant.
Cancelling the subscription – Now the moment of truth… Is there a lot of hoops to jump through, phone calls to make, just so that you can cancel the subscription? No, absolutely none of that nonsense. You literally just log into the dashboard and click that you want to cancel. Done… Now there really isn’t any reason for you to not try them out! It’s completely risk free!
Get your free pair from On That Ass
| Category | Score | My Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | 9/10 | Comfy and very easy to move about in |
| Breathability | 8/10 | Breathable cotton material |
| Riding Up | 10/10 | None |
| Leg Length | 5/10 | Short leg only. I would be a full subscriber if they done long leg versions! |
| Design / Range | 10/10 | Some of the best patterns available anywhere |
| Value for Money | 8/10 | £12.99 a pair is fair enough for the quality |
What I Look For in a Good Boxer
Comfort — Does it feel good immediately, and does that hold up over a full day?
Riding up — The dealbreaker. If it’s going up, it’s going in the bin.
Breathability — Especially in summer or during any physical activity.
Leg length — Personal preference, but I’ll always tell you which you’re getting. I prefer long leg.
Durability — How does it hold up after washing? Waistband, material, shape.
Value — Cost per pair matters. A £15 boxer needs to justify itself against a £4 one.
Got a brand I should add to the list? Suggest it here.
