Don’t Buy On That Ass Boxers Until You Read This Review

Looking to compare all the boxer brands I’ve tested? Head over to the Best Men’s Boxer Shorts UK roundup – I’ve ranked every brand I’ve tried so you can see how they all stack up.

On That Ass came up on my radar when I was looking at boxer subscription services. The hook is a free first pair – you sign up, they send you a pair at no cost, and then it becomes a monthly subscription from there (IF you want to). I signed up, got my free pair, tested them properly, and also went through the cancellation process to see how easy it actually is. Here’s everything.

No marketing BS, no sponsored content. That’s the No BS Reviews promise.

Who Are On That Ass?

On That Ass are a Dutch underwear subscription brand with a strong UK presence. The model is simple: your first pair is free, then you receive a new pair each month at £12.99 unless you cancel or pause. They’re known for bold, graphic designs (similar territory to OddBalls) and the subscription angle means you’re constantly getting something new without having to actively shop. They ship to the UK with no issues.

Get your free pair from On That Ass

Overall Score

CategoryScoreVerdict
Comfort9/10Snug fit that works — well constructed and easy to move in
Breathability8/10Good for everyday wear
Riding Up10/10Stayed put completely — not once all day
Leg Length5/10Standard length only — no long leg option
Design / Range10/10Excellent — bold designs that actually look good
Value for Money8/10£12.99/month is fair; free first pair is a genuine win
Overall8.5/10One of the best pairs I’ve tested — only let down by no long leg option

Comfort – 9/10

These fit slightly snugger than my usual boxers, which I noticed immediately when I first put them on. That’s by design — On That Ass use a closer cut than a lot of UK brands. I was initially unsure about it, but once I’d worn them for a bit, I barely noticed. They’re well constructed, move with you rather than against you, and there’s no rubbing or irritation. Genuinely one of the most comfortable pairs I’ve tested.

Breathability – 8/10

Good breathability for everyday wear. Nothing remarkable either way — they do what you’d expect from a well-made pair of boxers. Not a performance fabric, so I wouldn’t necessarily pick these for sport, but for a full day’s wear there are no complaints. See how they compare to the more performance-focused options in the full roundup.

Riding Up – 10/10

Not once. The snug cut actually works in their favour here — there’s less excess material to bunch up or shift around. Wore them all day and didn’t need to adjust once. Full marks.

Leg Length – 5/10

The only real weakness. On That Ass only offer one length, which sits on the shorter side. It’s not uncomfortable, and the snug cut means it doesn’t feel as brief as it looks, but if you specifically prefer long leg boxers this is a dealbreaker. If they introduced a long leg version, I’d be a full subscriber without hesitation. For now, 5/10 on principle.

Design / Range – 10/10

Excellent. The designs are bold, well-executed and genuinely look good — not just novelty prints for the sake of it. The subscription model means the range rotates constantly, so you’re not stuck looking at the same few options. If you’re into distinctive underwear rather than plain basics, the design quality here is right up there with the best I’ve seen.

Value for Money – 8/10

The free first pair makes this a very easy recommendation to try. After that, £12.99 a month is fair for the quality you’re getting — it’s not cheap, but you’re getting a decent pair of boxers every month rather than something that’ll fall apart after three washes. If the subscription doesn’t suit you, cancellation is simple — log into the dashboard and cancel. No calls, no hoops, no dark patterns. That matters.

What I Liked

  • Free first pair is a genuine, no-strings offer
  • One of the most comfortable pairs I’ve tested — the snug cut works
  • Zero riding up all day
  • Bold, well-designed prints that actually look good
  • Cancellation is easy — dashboard only, no hassle
  • Good everyday breathability

What I Didn’t Like

  • No long leg option — standard length only
  • The snug cut takes a minute to get used to if you’re not expecting it
  • £12.99 a month adds up if you forget to pause or cancel

Are On That Ass Worth Buying?

Yes – especially at the free first pair entry point. These are genuinely well-made boxers with great designs, and the subscription model is fair as long as you stay on top of it. The only thing stopping them scoring higher is the lack of a long leg option — sort that out and they’d be right at the top of this list.

Get your free first pair here — no catch, cancel any time from the dashboard.

See how On That Ass compares to every other brand I’ve tested in the Best Men’s Boxer Shorts UK roundup.

FAQs

Is On That Ass actually free?
The first pair is genuinely free — you just cover a small shipping charge. After that it becomes a monthly subscription at £12.99 per pair unless you cancel or pause.

How do you cancel On That Ass?
Log into your account dashboard and cancel from there. No phone calls, no retention hoops — straightforward self-serve cancellation. I did it myself to test it and it took about two minutes.

Are On That Ass boxers good quality?
Yes. Well constructed, comfortable and they don’t ride up. The snug cut is by design and works better than it sounds once you’re wearing them.

How much does On That Ass cost per month?
£12.99 per month after your free first pair. You can pause or cancel any time through your account dashboard.

Do On That Ass boxers ride up?
Not in my experience. The snug cut actually helps — there’s less material to shift around. Wore them all day without adjusting once.

Do On That Ass offer long leg boxers?
Not currently — standard length only. If long leg is important to you, that’s worth knowing before you sign up. It’s the main thing I’d change about them.

How do On That Ass compare to OddBalls?
Both score well on design and riding up, but On That Ass edges it on comfort and overall quality. OddBalls have a bigger static range to browse; On That Ass keep things fresh through the subscription rotation. See the full Best Men’s Boxer Shorts UK comparison for the full breakdown.

John Gorevan

John Gorevan is one guy doing no BS reviews and serving up nostalgia dopamine hits since 2019. He tests products properly with honest review and No BS fluff and writes about the geek culture and childhood memories that still hit different. Over 135,000 readers and counting.

Leave a Comment

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
×